Gristedes WIC Dispute Heats Up On Roosevelt Island

Updated 4 years ago Peter McCarthy
Gristedes Roosevelt Island Store
Gristedes Roosevelt Island Store
© David Stone / The Roosevelt Island Daily

While Assembly Member Rebecca Seawright searches for a solution to the WIC issues, Gristedes reaches out to the media for support, prompting protest leader Frank Farance to cry, "Foul!"

"Catsimatidis is fibbing," shot back Frank Farance. Catsimatidis is Jim, the supermarket's owner, and Farance terms it "Gristedes WIC gouging."

WIC is a federal program, administered locally, that seeks to provide critical nutritional support for at risk children under five and their mothers. On August 12th, Gristedes and Catsimatidis other chain, Red Apple, abruptly dropped out.

“We try very hard to service the needs of the community, and were very sad to stop taking WIC after supporting the program for decades,” said John Catsimatidis, quoted in the Roosevelt Islander Blog. “This decision was not made lightly, but the current implementation of the WIC program has made our continued participation impractical."

The core of Catsimatidis argument results form a change in the New York WIC program.

Instead of a "not to exceed" price included in the order forms which become check deposits, there is a blank, leaving the store owner in the dark, according to Catsimatidis. Gristedes deposits the WIC checks as always, but because of an administrative change to counter fraud, an individual item price that exceeds an approved amount (known to the State) results in a bounced check.

Previously, the owner says, the State would simply reduce the the amount to an approved level and accept the check.

The change costs Gristedes $10 per bounced check, a hefty price to pay for an already reduced item.

In a New York post story by John Crudelle, the writer reports, "In fact, the company showed me hundreds of WIC checks that had bounced in July alone. Checks that were used to pay $8 or $5 orders all came back with $10 bounce fees from the bank."

Hard not to sympathize with Gristedes on that one.

But wait a minute. Not so fast, according to Farance.

As for the bounced checks, Catsimatidis "fibs about the reasoning, which he is well aware of. The Vendor Management Agency told me they conveyed (the problem) to Gristedes. For example, the VMA  griped that Gristedes was charging $26 for infant formula."

That is, Gristedes is deliberately overcharging, according to Farance, and should have known their prices would bounce as reliably as soccer balls off kickers' feet.

Farance continues, "The NYS Department of Health official told me that all vendors know quickly about the pricing of their peers, and the limits on pricing, as it is described in the vendor management handbook in dealing with a bounced check.

"Simply, Gristedes could have avoided the bounced checks (as described in the vendor management handbook and as the VMA advised) by not overcharging and keeping in line with their Manhattan peers."

Bolstering his argument, both the New York State Department of Health and the VMA report that no other chains are dropping out of the program. Only Gristedes seems to have an unmanageable bounced check problem.

As of this writing, the issue remains unresolved. Assembly Member Seawright is trying to find a solution and will have more to say as developments continue. But it does not appear that community pressure to date has been enough to change Gristedes's decision.

Comments powered by Disqus

#CommissionsEarned

Assorted Ideas Group

The enduring allure of conspiracies

Reset Conspiracy theories seem to meet psychological needs and can be almost impossible to eradicate. One remedy: Keep them from taking root in the first place. By Greg Miller 1.14.2021 Assorted Ideas, Large & Small The United States of America was founded on a conspiracy theory. In the […]

The post The enduring allure of conspiracies appeared first on Assorted Ideas, Large & Small.

Inside the Capitol Riot: What the Parler Videos Reveal

ProPublica is a Pulitzer Prize-winning investigative newsroom. Sign up for The Big Story newsletter to receive stories like this one in your inbox. This story originally appeared in ProPublica. by Alec MacGillis/ProPublica The man’s smartphone camera pans the crowd on the east side of the U.S. Capitol. It’s smaller […]

The post Inside the Capitol Riot: What the Parler Videos Reveal appeared first on Assorted Ideas, Large & Small.

At protests that draw counter-protesters, people on the left more likely to face arrest

by Clark Merrefield, Journalist’s ResourceJanuary 12, 2021 As hundreds of President Donald Trump’s supporters took over the U.S. Capitol Jan. 6, journalists chronicled the striking differences in how law enforcement officials treated the insurrectionists compared with how they treated racial justice protesters who marched in dozens of cities […]

The post At protests that draw counter-protesters, people on the left more likely to face arrest appeared first on Assorted Ideas, Large & Small.

Q&A: In a picture – dancing about particle physics

The idea to do a dance performance about neutrino physics happened through serendipity. It was October 2015, and it was soon after the announcement of the Nobel Prize in physics (to Takaaki Kajita and Arthur B. McDonald for the discovery of neutrino oscillations, which shows that these sub-atomic particles […]

The post Q&A: In a picture – dancing about particle physics appeared first on Assorted Ideas, Large & Small.

About 700,000 parents with young kids left the workforce in 2020. For many, loss of child care was to blame.

Only about half of child care jobs lost at the start of the pandemic have returned, leading to a 144 percent increase in the number of parents who have missed work to care for children, according to new data analysis.  Chabeli Carrazana Originally published by The 19th Coronavirus […]

The post About 700,000 parents with young kids left the workforce in 2020. For many, loss of child care was to blame. appeared first on Assorted Ideas, Large & Small.