Glorifying the Old South as It Never Was

Why Gone With The Wind Is the Worst Movie Ever Made

Peter McCarthy
Vivien Leigh as Scarlett O'Hara in Gone With the Wind
Vivien Leigh as Scarlett O'Hara in Gone With the Wind
Photo is in the Public Domain

Every time Gone With The Wind fills the screen with its dishonest portrait of the Old South as it was before the Civil War, I cringe. 

About the Worst Movie Ever Made

This movie is a classic because Vivian Leigh's work as a conflicted Scarlett is unforgettably heroic and Clark Gable's as Rhett is the classic movie peak of rugged individualism.

Their acclaim is well-earned. But that doesn't justify the extra baggage, the romanticizing of a culture built on slavery, for example, that comes with it.

Better choices for classic movie lovers...


The movie's popularity alone is a crucial piece in earning Gone With The Wind the distinction of Worst Movie Ever Made.

Other bad movies filled with bad ideas are forgotten or resurrected in order to be mocked, but not Gone With The Wind.

Gone With The Wind has been embedded in our culture. People watch it now with the same indiscretion as they show in drinking sugar water (otherwise known as soft drinks), the dangers invisible and ignored.

From scene one, this movie depicts southern plantation owners as benign innocents, loyal to their homeland, maybe a little ignorant, determined to sustain the prettified honor of their culture.

That culture, we are expected to ignore, was impossible without the enslavement of millions of African laborers, almost all the descendants of free people kidnapped and brought across the ocean in terrible conditions that resulted in cruel deaths, estimated at 20% of the human cargo, before reaching America.

Not once do we see slaves beaten or punished for not obeying the masters, a common practice on plantations for keeping order. A gross exaggeration of reality finds loyal slaves marching off to defend the Confederacy while Atlanta is falling around them.

Never do we see any of the mixed race children that were common on plantations because slave owners routinely raped the women they “owned." 

Instead, we see docile servants, each happy to serve the O'Hara family in the big house. They are undistinguishable from the household servants in contemporary films of the time, just part of the family but not quite as bright or independent.

Why Gone With The Wind Is the Worst Movie Ever Made

The War as Modern Day Romantics Prefer

It's hard to say it's worse than how slavery is misrepresented, but the depictions of war may be.

As the South falls, tens of thousands injured and dead, Sherman's march on Atlanta is shown like a fall into a hell of the North's creation. The victimized Southerners, including the loyal slaves, descend into crime only as their city burns around them.

Scarlett makes her escape, loyal, ignorant servant along for the ride, with Rhett's gallant help.

We never hear that the South initiated the Civil War by attacking Fort Sumter or that their heroic General Robert E. Lee sustained the Confederacy by grinding out one of the most efficient killing machines in the history of the world up to that time. We don’t hear that he invaded the North in an attempt to take the capital and the rest of the country, safe for slavery, with it.

Three-quarters of a million people were lost because, more than anything else, the South was desperate to keep slavery and the plantation culture it supported alive — on the backs of millions of lives in chains.

Finally, scenes of the terrible suffering of soldiers returned maimed and dying to the streets of Atlanta, ignoring their dubious cause, are heartbreaking, another suggestion of Southerners dying for a just cause.

Nearby in Andersonville, Union prisoners are held in the most deplorable conditions humanity has ever known, dying in filth from disease and hunger. Andersonville, where the noble Southerners inflicted the grossest inhumanity on thousands of helpless prisoners goes unmentioned in Gone With the Wind.

Reality would spoil the fantasy of the horrors the South committed to save slavery.

The American Civil War was the worst disaster in our history. More people died than in all our other wars combined.

It was fought when the Confederacy invoked their claim for States Rights because their entire economy was dependent on massive slavery and they feared that it would be banned.


Gone With The Wind sustains the myth of Southern honor, as if there really was more at stake than preserving culture dependent on kidnapping, rape and enslavement.

And it romanticizes conditions to the extent that it's impossible to see any evil in the pre-war Southern plantation lifestyle. Why would Northerners ever want to destroy the charms and grace of the South?

I hate this movie, its endless propaganda.

That it has become an admired classic is a demonstration of our national preference for romanticized ignorance over reality.

It's almost as if slavery didn't exist, certainly none of its evils, except as a detached concept.

Disclaimer: I once wrote that Amadeus was the worst movie ever made, but I was wrong. I didn't realize that it was really Gone With The Wind until I made the mistake of trying to watch this lump of soupy propaganda recently. I apologize to the makers of Amadeus for knocking it off the pedestal.

Gone with the Wind is the worst movie ever made, an exploitation film designed to clean up the horror of slavery and replace it with a genteel fantasy of sophisticated plantation owners victimized by the North.

What do you think?

Comments powered by Disqus

Assorted Ideas

Amanda Matthews Picked for Nellie Bly Monument

RIOC Picks Amanda Matthews for Nellie Bly Monument “The Girl Puzzle” will be located in Lighthouse Park The Roosevelt Island Operating Corporation (RIOC) selected Amanda Matthews/Prometheus Art to construct the Nellie Bly Monument. The installation lands on the northern end of Roosevelt Island at Lighthouse Park. Recently, Lighthouse Park hostedContinue Reading

The post Amanda Matthews Picked for Nellie Bly Monument appeared first on Assorted Ideas, Large & Small.

Worth & Nancy Howe Return

Worth & Nancy Howe return to Roosevelt Island on October 26th when RIOC celebrates naming The Howe Theatre in the Cultural Center. The Howes pioneered MST&DA’s expanding role in community life. When we learned that Worth and Nancy Howe were leaving Roosevelt Island, I wrote a tribute. In Los Angeles,Continue Reading

The post Worth & Nancy Howe Return appeared first on Assorted Ideas, Large & Small.

What the hell’s going on with Blackwell House?

What the hell’s going on with Blackwell House? The question popped into my head last week when I saw the historic landmark under a protective wrap again. In a Roosevelt Islander blog post, they asked, “… at what point will the condition of Blackwell House be such that it can be used forContinue Reading

The post What the hell’s going on with Blackwell House? appeared first on Assorted Ideas, Large & Small.

Indonesian Fire Hits NYC

How an Indonesian Fire hits New York City… “It is with very heavy hearts we announce that Presbyterian Orphanage in Tomohon, where we found Mathew Tendean Luce 24 years ago, was burned to the ground,” wrote Roosevelt Island based humanitarian Jim Luce. No children were harmed, but there’s a surprisingContinue Reading

The post Indonesian Fire Hits NYC appeared first on Assorted Ideas, Large & Small.

Christopher Columbus Opposing Views

Christopher Columbus, Opposing Views adds a fresh angle to a debate we’ve had here since 2017. My critical view of the man who “discovered” America was countered by my friend, historian Ron Musto. And now, a new point of view emerges. “Understanding the truth about Christopher Columbus is not soContinue Reading

The post Christopher Columbus Opposing Views appeared first on Assorted Ideas, Large & Small.