Logstanding Disputes Come To A Head On Friday

Are 2-4 River Road Tenants and Manhattan Park Management On Collision Course?

Updated 4 weeks ago David Stone
Manhattan Park market rate building at 30 River Road. Subsidized tenants at 2-4 share similar complaints.
Manhattan Park market rate building at 30 River Road. Subsidized tenants at 2-4 share similar complaints.
© David Stone / Roosevelt Island Daily

On April 5th, the Tenant Association representing 2-4 River Road confronted Property Manager Michael Kim with a list of grievances, all longstanding. A "formal meeting" with management and residents on Friday is scheduled to address concerns from both sides.

For its part, Manhattan Park Management answered, "We were surprised by your statement that Grenadier has 'refused' to remedy the issues in the Letter and that these matters have become 'urgent.'"

Grenadier Reality manages Manhattan Park.

The opposing groups seem to live in different worlds, not an unusual occurrence with landlords and renters, but this dispute is seasoned by the fact that virtually all leases for the buildings are subsidized under Section 8 funding from the federal Housing and Urban Development Department.

HUD rules for the program are complex, and from management's perspective, some grievances reflect difficulties inherent in dealing with the program. This includes recertification procedures, utility allowances and guidelines for crediting income, earned and unearned, from residents who are students.

But the association insists there's more to the story, citing multiple recertifications in a single year, unacceptable housekeeping and failures to come through with renovations.

For example, a gym was built and equipped, as promised, but the association objects that, rather than install new treadmills, stationary bikes and other fitness equipment, management simply moved older equipment from 40 River Road, a market rate building also managed by Grenadier, into theirs.

Lobby renovations, also a point of contention, are currently being "bid out," according to management, with an eye on completing the work before year's end.  

While poor communications may be a critical element, tenants ire has been raised when Manhattan Park staff, they claim, interacted with them "in a manner that many felt bordered on harassment."

But probably the longest simmering dispute involves heating, which tenants believe is inadequate and overly expensive. It's also been an issue with other Manhattan Park buildings.

"The heating system needs to be repaired," the Tennant Association said. "It does not adequately generate enough heat in tenants’ apartments. Yet still produces high electric bills. We were told there would be a new heating system installed, apartments would be weatherized, and an engineer would come in to inspect the current system. We have neither heard or seen of any of this happening."

Management pushed back, "We understand that there are concerns about heating and we make every effort to ensure that all heating equipment is working properly," they said, adding, "We have engaged an independent engineer to explore other heating options for the building but can make no promises at the current time if any of these options are feasible."

On Friday, we will get a better idea of how deep is the gap between Grenadier and its tenants and how likely it is to be bridged soon. 

Comments powered by Disqus

Assorted Ideas

Clotilda, My Friend’s Story About the Last Shave Ship to America

When I read that the Clotilda, a schooner that was known to be the last slave ship to America, had been found, I recalled a conversation with my friend Sylviane Diouf from years ago. No one expected to ever find the vessel about which she’d just written a book, until a bomb cyclone exposed it … Continue reading Clotilda, My Friend’s Story About the Last Shave Ship to America →

It’s a Wonderful World: New York’s Annual Duck Parade

“It’s typical for female mallards to make nests and lay eggs in well-protected areas like high-walled courtyards. It’s also common at this time of year to see mama ducks leading hatchlings away from nesting areas to nearby bodies of water. “What isn’t so common is for a mama duck to use her bill to tap … Continue reading It’s a Wonderful World: New York’s Annual Duck Parade →

“To move the world…”

Socrates’ “Move The World” Quote Poster (Blue) by MementoStudios Want to make a difference? What are you waiting for? One more reason to love Socrates. He knew, 2,500 years ago.

Did Abraham-Hicks Kill Ari?

Did Esther Hicks or her late husband Jerry Hicks help — or their “teachings” — precipitate the death of Ari, an artist who turned to the Abraham-Hicks controlled Abe Forum for support? Here’s the story, pieced together from the accounts of friends outraged over what occurred and efforts to hide the tragedy. If Esther Hicks, … Continue reading Did Abraham-Hicks Kill Ari? →

“More Or Less I Am” Celebrates Whitman’s 200th Birthday in New York City

“Whitman’s own manic enthusiasm might be required to describe the joyous jamboree that occurs when you combine a fiddle, flute, cello, guitar, and steel drum with readers from the audience, an opera singer, the sounds of jets flying overhead and bells ringing at Riverside Church, the guy who played Brother Mouzone on The Wire, and … Continue reading “More Or Less I Am” Celebrates Whitman’s 200th Birthday in New York City →

You purchase helps The Daily Keep publishing...